“Moms” by Shivani Sibal
p.28-30 She had forgotten, in that moment, that mothers were not free to express their own emotions — that they were always expected to be the bigger person every single bloody time, to respond reasonably and pleasantly always, no matter the provocation.
She caught herself, regaining her composure almost immediately, but the guilt set in like a heavy weight. Feeling rotten, she gave Samara a toffee and suggested they download a new game together.
Manik came home one evening, just around Saramar’s bedtime, to find mother and daughter engrossed in their respective devices. ‘You only have one child. Surely, yu can teach her something beyond this tap-tap-tap?’ he said, snatching the iPad from the little girl’s hands, prompting a iercing shriek. ‘What is it that keeps you so busy? This thing?’ he continued, grabbing Radhika’s phone. ‘Drop Samu off with Malti Didi and come back, please,’ he commanded. ‘At least she’ll read to her in Hindi. That’s something, more than you.’
Fighting back the tears pooling in her eyes, Radhika picked up a still-sobbing Samara, handed her over to Malti Didi and wearily went to her room to try and compose herself. Manik was standing on the attached balcony, her phone in his hand.
‘Come out here, Radhika,’ he said, filling her with a familiar sense of foreboding. What would happen now? She stepped out onto the balcony and noticed some fireworks going off in the distance. Without another word, Manik dropped her phone down three floors to the gorund, narrowly missing one of the parked cars. There was a loud thud, prompting the nigh guard to come and investigate. He looked up to see sahib and memsahib standing far above on the highest balcony. Manike waved him away with a flick of his hand.
‘Now, go down, Radhika, get that beloved phone of yours back, and I want to see that girl educated. Do justice to all she’s been born with. All the other kids have a committed hobby by now. Samu should be there in two years. Make it happen.’ He grabbed her by the head, pulled her close and kissed her roughly, his hand pinching her nipples hard. ‘Come right back. I’ll be waiting.’
Manik lit a cigarette and leant against the railing, watching as Radhika appeared on the ground below. She seemed to be explaining to the guard that the phone had fallen by accident.
Radhika began enrolling Samara in every class she could think of, determined to make up for lost time. Naina’s daughter attended ballet lessons with a Kazakh teacher, reputedly the best in town, so Samara was promptly signed up for those. A handwriting tutor came to the house twice a week. Swimming lessons were held in the lap pool on the terrace, with a few neighbourhood children invited to join in. Weekends became a dizzying rotation of chess, Hindustani classical singing, LEGO and art.
‘I’m so tired, Mama,’ Samara complained one afternoon. She was far from thrilled with the whirlwind of self-improvement that she had taken over her life, especially as no one had asked for her opinion.
‘Papa really wants this, Beta, and you did enjoy the class. You were laughing when it was over,’ Radhika replied. ‘I saw your handwriting — it’s beautiful, so much better than Devi’s . . . I mean . . . ‘ she quickly caught herself; one must never compare children. ‘So different from Devi’s. Not better or worse. Just different,’ she corrected attempting to smooth things over.
‘I was laughing because I was relieved it was over,’ Samara muttered, picking at her cuticles.
Shivani Sibal’s second novel Moms is about Radhika Khanna who married young and is a part of Delhi society. Her husband Manik is a successful lawyer and Radhika knows no want even if she has to ask Raja, Mani’s assistant, for money, usually after her husband has given his assent. She is financially dependant on her husband. Even her position on their daughter’s school board is courtesy her husband’s client, the school proprietors. Radhika does everything that her husband asks of her including keeping her weight in check by stepping on the weighing scales daily. Figuring out what to eat or not to eat. Changing clothes regularly with a seemingly limitless budget as that is what Manik desires. From the outside, it seems that Radhika is leaving the enviable charmed life of every rich woman, being the brand ambassador of her family, wearing the latest jewellery designs and clothes, driving in the most expensive cars, living in a swank neighbourhood and becoming a member of exclusive clubs. Yet, she is always on an edge, jumpy, unable to manage her own time as Manik micromanages it for her, leaving her little breathing space. He punishes her for perceived transgressions at the drop of a hat and rewards her generously, say with a Cartier bracelet, if she does everything per his bidding. Her punishments may include be locked up in his walk-in closet with the lights switched off or snipping of pieces of her hair in such a manner that others would not know but Radhika would. Or breaking her expensive mobile phone. The list is endless. She is a bird in a gilded cage.
The novel is structured in three parts. The first and brief opening is about Radhika’s daily routine that ends in jumping off her bedroom balcony. The other two parts are devoted to life before and after marriage. There is a deadpan way in which Manik’s dominance over Radhika is described. It is precise and clearly etched. Nothing more. The violence depicted is real and is being played out in many relationships on a daily basis. What is truly horrifiying is how the male perpetrator directs his pointed anger towards the woman victim in a manner that ensures he leaves no visible physical mark on her body. Unfortunately, the truth is that mental and psychological scars are formed, never to be healed, never to be visible, and always stacking up one on top of the other, till, for many, there is only one escape route left. Death.
Moms exemplifies that irrespective of socio-economic class, women continue to be subjugated by patriarchy. Men embody it, exercise it, are entitled to it without realising that they are entitled, Novels have a purpose at times to hold up a mirror to society, to the reader to discover for themselves behaviours that are not necessarily “normal”, more likely abusive. Moms achieves it to a degree. It shows but the narrative, story plot, or even the perspectives offered by various characters lack the depth that one would expect in a conversation regarding violence towards women, their identity, their space etc. It is commercial fiction and not literary fiction, but even so, it could have been a little more nuanced. Be that as it may, some of the best ways in which women are portrayed, the conversations that they have had in hyper-patriarchal structures and their push back are to be found in commercial fiction. And this is a critical function of contemporary literature. To communicate with readers various scenarios that may occur in domestic spaces but are not accetable behaviour. Novels such as Moms offers a way of seeing but there is no getting away from the hint of complacency that exists in the upper echelons of society portrayed in the story; these behaviours exist but there is little that can be done about it. People guard their social bubble firmly.
Moms is a glimpse into Indian society that is a mix of old money, the nouveau riche and the aspirational indvidual. A far cry from the India that is visible across global media publications as that of a poverty-stricken nation. But the truth is harsh. Women, irrespective of the socio-economic layer that they inhabit, are vulnerable, still victims of patriarchy, and have little or no say in their lives. It will certainly make you reflect. It is suitable for a quick read.
PS While we should never judge a book by its cover, this book could have certainly done with a better cover.
15 Nov 2025

No Comments